Is EMDR Evidence-Based?

December 20, 2023

A woman showing signs of PTSD, highlighting Emdr therapy

EMDR (eye movement desensitization and reprocessing) is an evidence-based intervention proven effective for treating PTSD (post-traumatic stress disorder). Engaging in weekly sessions of EMDR over up to three months, individuals typically observe significant improvements, with many experiencing positive changes after just a few sessions. Read on to discover more about the following:

  • When was EMDR developed?
  • Is EMDR evidence based?
  • Is EMDR effective?
A man shows he is anxious at work as a result of ptsd, raising questions about Emdr therapy effectiveness

Is EMDR an Evidence-Based Practice?

Following a traumatic experience, individuals with PTSD often struggle to make sense of the events. EMDR therapy provides a structured approach to help process such traumas, streamlining the healing process. During EMDR sessions, individuals focus on a back-and-forth movement or sound while recalling the distressing memory. This targeted attention leads to shifts in how the memory is experienced, allowing for the processing of additional information from the past. Is EMDR evidence-based, though?

EMDR is considered an evidence-based practice for the treatment of PTSD. Numerous studies have established its effectiveness, and research often compares EMDR to other evidence-based modalities like trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy.

Meta-analyses of current literature suggest that EMDR and trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy are equally effective in the treatment of PTSD. 

an icon image of a lightbulb

Need Help Getting Mental Health Treatment?

Many international health and mental health organizations, including WHO (World Health Organization), APA (American Psychiatric Association), and ISTSS (International Society for Traumatic Stress Studies), have endorsed EMDR as a treatment for PTSD based on accumulated clinical research.

EMDR Therapy Effectiveness

How effective is EMDR, then? Research and clinical observations consistently support the effectiveness of EMDR as a therapeutic intervention for PTSD. Many studies have specifically focused on assessing the impact of EMDR in treating individuals with traumatic experiences, comparing its efficacy to other evidence-based treatments such as trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy. You can explore the research right here.

Why is EMDR so Controversial?

While EMDR has gained widespread acceptance as an effective PTSD treatment, it has not been without controversy. Several factors contribute to the debate surrounding EMDR, including:

  • Lack of clear mechanism explanation: Despite its proven efficacy, the exact mechanisms through which EMDR brings about therapeutic benefits are not fully understood. The adaptive information processing model proposed by Francine Shapiro offers an explanation, but some critics argue that the neurological and psychological processes involved require further clarification. This lack of a universally accepted theoretical framework has led to skepticism among some professionals in the mental health community.
  • Variability in treatment protocols: Another source of controversy stems from the variability in EMDR treatment protocols. While the core principles are consistent, the specific techniques used during sessions – including the nature of bilateral stimulation – can vary among practitioners. Critics argue that this lack of standardization may impact the reliability and reproducibility of results, making it challenging to establish a uniform approach to EMDR.
  • Debate over eye movements: The role of eye movements in EMDR is debated. Some studies suggest that the effectiveness of EMDR may not be solely attributed to eye movements, and alternative forms of bilateral stimulation, such as hand tapping or auditory tones, can yield similar therapeutic outcomes. This has prompted discussions about whether the eye movement component is essential to the success of the therapy.
  • Comparison to placebo effects: Opponents of EMDR have raised concerns about the potential influence of placebo effects. This debate highlights the need for continued research and rigorous examination of the therapy’s effects.

Research on EMDR

There is a robust body of research on EMDR.

Comparative studies with TF-CBT (trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy)

A number of studies have compared EMDR with TF-CBT, the primary evidence-based treatment for PTSD. These studies often assess the effectiveness of both approaches in reducing PTSD symptoms.

Meta-analyses and systematic reviews

Several meta-analyses and systematic reviews have been conducted to synthesize current findings. These comprehensive analyses contribute to the evidence base supporting EMDR as an effective intervention for PTSD.

Endorsements from international organizations

The endorsement of EMDR by esteemed international organizations like WHO and APA is rooted in a thorough examination of clinical research. These organizations have reviewed the available evidence and recognized EMDR as a valid and effective treatment for trauma-related conditions.

Clinical observations and case studies

Beyond controlled studies, clinical observations and case studies illuminate the real-world application of EMDR. Therapists may share their experiences and observations of how EMDR has positively impacted people with PTSD. These accounts may contribute to a broader understanding of the therapy’s effectiveness.

Ongoing research and emerging areas

As with any evolving field, ongoing research continues to explore new facets of EMDR. Researchers investigate its applicability to diverse populations, potential mechanisms underlying its effectiveness, and variations in treatment protocols. The evolving nature of research ensures that the understanding of EMDR remains dynamic and responsive to emerging scientific inquiries.

an image of people who got help at Connections Mental Health treatment for anxiety, depression, and ptsd

Get EMDR Treatment for Mental Health at Connections

If you feel that the effectiveness of EMDR might help you combat the distress triggered by PTSD, we can help you with this at Connections Mental Health in Southern California.

At our luxury beachside center, you can engage with personalized and evidence-based mental health treatment. We admit no more than six people at any one time, offering you a perfect mix of peer support and individualized attention as you work on improving well-being and restoring every functioning. Call 844-413-0009 to discuss how you can move beyond post-traumatic stress disorder in Southern California.

Want to Learn More?
Recent Articles
image depicting old age and mental health

July 11, 2024

Aging and How It Affects Mental Health

As you get older, certain life events like retiring, losing loved ones, or getting sick can affect your mental health. Although age and mental health

image depicting combat ptsd

July 8, 2024

Combat PTSD: Stats, Symptoms, & Recovery

Returning from military service and adjusting to life outside can be tough, especially when dealing with combat PTSD (post-traumatic stress disorder). While PTSD can be

image depicting art and mental health

July 8, 2024

The Link Between Art and Mental Health

Art and mental health are closely connected, offering many benefits. Painting, writing, or playing music can help improve focus, boost self-esteem, and reduce stress. Read

image depicting childhood trauma and depression

July 1, 2024

Childhood Trauma and Depression in Adulthood

Experts have studied the link between childhood trauma and depression in adulthood for many years. The evidence shows a clear connection between these experiences and

image depicting social rhythm therapy

June 28, 2024

Understanding Social Rhythm Therapy

Social rhythm therapy helps people keep a steady routine to manage their mood. You can feel better and avoid mood swings by sticking to regular

image depicting mental illness and family

June 24, 2024

The Role of Mental Illness in Family Dynamics

Mental illness and family relationships can be deeply affected during tough times. When someone in the family has a mental health issue, it can be

an image of people who got help at Connections Mental Health

You’re Not Alone

Get treatment from a team of expert staff who is passionate about helping you experience peace.

Learn more about the individual mental health disorders we treat by clicking a button below.